For many years, the common assumption was that the actress famous for Bride of Frankenstein had been cremated and her remains scattered in the ocean after her death in 1986.
But a Hollywood historian, founder of a company specializing in celebrity death sites, made a surprising discovery: her cremated remains were actually buried in a rose garden under her married name, Elsa Lanchester Laughton.
"For almost 40 years no one had made the connection – until this moment," he says.
An Interest for Hollywood's Dark Side
The historian, sixty-three, specializes in celebrity deaths and scandals. He has consulted for films such as the director's a film about the Manson murders.
Extremely dedicated about unsung Hollywood, he arranges charity events for marginalized or cult actors, including the actor known as Pinhead and Pugsley from Addams Family.
It was this interest that led Mr Michaels to look into what became of the actress's ashes.
The Life of Elsa Lanchester
Born on October 28, 1902 in London's Lewisham district, she was a young performer in theatre and musical shows, and even recorded albums of old ballads.
When she was 25 she married co-star Charles Laughton, and starred alongside him in a historical drama, for which Laughton won the Best Actor Oscar.
Laughton portrayed the lead character in the 1939 classic, and the pair worked on twelve films together, most notably Witness for the Prosecution in 1957, for which they were both Oscar-nominated.
Lanchester had been nominated before in 1949 for a drama, and after her husband's passing she continued to work regularly, including a number of family movies such as Mary Poppins and a comedy.
Recollections from Fellow Actors
Actor Bruce Davison, who starred as Willard alongside Lanchester as his controlling mother Henreitta, recalls warmly of their collaboration.
She told me: 'You know when a director is giving you a load of codswallop? What you do is say 'Oooh, that's very interesting, let me do that.' And then just do whatever the hell you want!' he chuckles.
He also remembered an incident that would excite horror fans now.
"I brought a home movie camera to set, and one time I recorded her at the staircase when she recreated her Bride role," he added. "She appreciated for the Bride role," she recognized its impact on her career.
The Puzzle of Where She Was Buried
While the 1935 film – in which her hair was stretched up over a special effects frame – secured her a place in film history, the question of what happened to her remains after her death was less well recorded.
In her autobiography that she did not like the site of her husband's grave in a famous cemetery – Laughton died in 1962. She stated she would rather to be burned with no ceremony, which is a reason everyone assumed for years that her ashes had been scattered.
The Expert's Early Interest with Death
An interest in death started young for the tour guide, who was raised in Detroit.
He recalls observing the funeral canopy at a family funeral and asking his mom "is this a circus?" He was three years old.
More than that, the family home was on one of the most dangerous intersections in the urban area. As a boy heard – and saw so many collisions that it almost became business as usual, and the springboard for an unique profession honoring those who have died.
When he learned of Lanchester's interment, during his ongoing investigations into historic death certificates, he determined she would be his next memorial project.
A Legacy That Deserves Recognition
Her seven-minute, dialogue-free performance alongside Boris Karloff as the Bride was legendary – she earned to have her legacy remembered.
After all, she was essentially the only female star of the Universal Horror cast.
"Many people also forget that she portrayed the author at the start of the film," Mr Michaels says.
Attention toward the actress had been sparked earlier in the year when the film studio issued products and collector's versions of the classic to mark the film's nine-decade milestone.
It was a surprise when the historian discovered that her representative had placed her ashes at a cemetery in North Hollywood – and that her ashes had remained interred as was commonly thought.
"Maybe she didn't really care about what occurred posthumously," he speculates.
An Appropriate Memorial
Within a day and a half, Mr Michaels had crowdfunded enough for a commemorative plaque to recognize this horror legend.
The unveiling ceremony will be conducted on October 28 – the anniversary of her birth.
"I aimed to commemorate on her 123rd birth anniversary," Michaels says, "and truly I forgot that it was just a few days before the spooky season."